News item: Borders to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
I have shopped at bookstores since I was… well, since well before I was old enough to drive. I had my favorite bookstore in Beaumont, TX, in the Los Angeles area, and in Dallas. (My favorite, of all time, was Acres of Books in Long Beach, a used bookstore that was, truly, acres of books. Not attractive, dusty, “old,” wonderful! It is now closed, as I read on Wikipedia).
When we moved to Dallas in 1987, I shopped at Taylor’s Bookstore. A locally owned “small chain,” it’s location in the outer parking lot of NorthPark Center was ideal. I could always park right in front, and get lost for a few hours.
The big national chain stores put Taylors out of business, and I switched to Borders. For some reason, I always liked Borders better than Barnes & Noble – no, I don’t know why. Just the feel of the store.
But I helped put Borders out of business. Because, for the last few years, I have spent far more at Amazon.com that I do at the physical stores. So, it’s partly my fault – but it is still sad.
The bookseller’s finances crumbled amid declining interest in bricks-and-mortar booksellers, a broad cultural trend for which it had no answers. The company suffered a series of management gaffes, piled up unsustainable debts and failed to cultivate a meaningful presence on the Internet or in increasingly popular digital e-readers.
The article seems to imply that Borders’ problems are significantly Borders’ fault. But, let’s say that Barnes & Noble is better managed, better run, with its Nook, and on-line business, developed in a pretty timely manner. Here’s the thing: I’m loyal to Amazon on-line, and have never once even checked Barnes & Noble’s site.
And, it really doesn’t matter. Here’s the future, from later in the article:
Online shopping and the advent of e-readers, with their promise of any book, any time, anywhere, and cheaper pricing, have shoppers abandoning Borders and Barnes & Nobles bookstores as they did music stores a decade ago.
“I think that there will be a 50 percent reduction in bricks-and-mortar shelf space for books within five years and 90 percent within 10 years,” says Mike Shatzkin, chief executive of Idea Logical Co., a New York consulting firm. “Bookstores are going away.”
“Bookstores are going away.” It’s a sad day.
And for this blog, which focuses on business issues and ideas and business books, here’s the question – are you in a business that can shift and change and adapt with the times, or are your days numbered also?
Washington, Nov. 21, 1864.
I have been shown in the files of the War Department a statement of the Adjutant General of Massachusetts that you are the mother of five sons who have died gloriously on the field of battle.
I feel how weak and fruitless must be any word of mine which should attempt to beguile you from the grief of a loss so overwhelming. But I cannot refrain from tendering you the consolation that may be found in the thanks of the Republic they died to save.
I pray that our Heavenly Father may assuage the anguish of your bereavement, and leave you only the cherished memory of the loved and lost, and the solemn pride that must be yours to have laid so costly a sacrifice upon the altar of freedom.
Yours, very sincerely and respectfully,
I’ve had quite a trip down memory lane today. First, I thought about a faded old volume which was faded and old when I bought it. Then, I thought of where I bought it. And then I thought of all that will be lost because of the arrival of modern technology.
Here’s the story. I opened my usual web sites this morning, and here was this wonderful article on Slate.com.
Hey, Mr. Postman: Why e-mail can never replace the letter, by Megan Marshall. She writes:
It never fails. No matter the place—cocktail party, lecture hall, classroom—whenever someone learns that I spent 20 years researching and writing a biography based on the handwritten letters of three 19th-century sisters, the question is promptly raised. How are biographies of 21st-century subjects going to get written when people today just don’t send letters—or, if they do, their letters take the evanescent form of e-mail?
So, as I read her article, I thought about my books in storage. They’ve been there for quite a few years. I need to sell them, but don’t want to part with them. Most of them are from my full-time ministry days, but many are not overtly ministry related (I confess, my speaking is still a kind of “ministry,” and everything is related. But that’s another discussion).
The volume that popped into mind was The World’s Great Letters. I have no idea if my volume is the one pictured here – I know that the cover was different. But I loved that book, and it is one that I need to rescue from storage and rediscover. It was the book that introduced me to Lincoln’s letter to Mrs. Bixby. Yes, I know that some of the facts behind the letter are in dispute – but who cares. It truly is one of the world’s great letters.
And thinking of the book brought to mind a wondrous oft-repeated experience from my Long Beach, California days. There was this used book store in Long Beach – Acres of Books. I swear the name was apt. You could get lost in there, as I frequently did. As much as I appreciate Half-Price Books in Dallas, there is simply nothing to compare to that beloved Acres of Books. They had every kind of book imaginable – acres of them. There is no telling how much (time, and money) I spent in that store – but I loved the hours I spent walking the aisles, sitting on the floor, even reading the clippings that they taped/glued/posted on the ends of rows of book shelves. Acres of Books even has its own Wikipedia entry – sadly, it is now closed.
Now closed – which brings me to the unstoppable march of modern technology. Not only has the internet threatened all of the book stores, new and used, it has threatened the very way we think and write. For example, at the Huntington Library in Pasadena, California, scholars can pour over original manuscripts from renowned authors (including, among many others, the original manuscript of Benjamin Franklin’s autobiography), seeing the very editing marks left by the authors themselves. Today, in many instances, only a final draft survives. With the click of a mouse, we hit save, and the editing decision, and example for future writers, is lost.
So, yes, the Slate.com article was correct. E-mail cannot replace the letter. And I do not expect to ever read “The World’s Great E-mails,” much less “The World’s Great Tweets” or its companion volume, “The World’s Great Text Messages.”
I welcome the new technology. It has helped in so many, many ways. – But, also…what a loss.